I am not opposed to the unorthodox, clever, or even severe consequence when one of my students (or one of my children) misbehaves. As much positive feedback as I offer my students and kids on a daily basis, there are moments when a consequence is needed and warranted.
But when it comes to punishments, I don't believe in acting cruel or unnecessarily harsh (though some of my former students may disagree).
So I'm not exactly sure how to feel about this father, who rightfully punished his daughter by taking away her phone (and thus eliminating her ability to send and receive text messages) but hours later slipped this sheet of paper under her bedroom door.
But cruel? Maybe.
I don't know the relationship this father has with his daughter, so perhaps this is part of a running gag, or maybe his daughter was primed for a joke like this. Maybe he was trying to make her laugh.
But judging this on face value alone? I'm not sure.
It's funny and unforgettable and imaginative, but I'm not sure that I could do it, simply because it strikes me as too mean.
Coming from me, that's really saying something.